Comments on: Poll: What separation pattern do you prefer in Silverlight http://joel.neubeck.net/2009/02/poll-separation-pattern/ Simplifing structure without changing results Sun, 23 May 2010 01:08:09 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0 By: bill simons http://joel.neubeck.net/2009/02/poll-separation-pattern/comment-page-1/#comment-756 bill simons Wed, 11 Feb 2009 03:26:53 +0000 http://joel.neubeck.net/?p=334#comment-756 Tim I wish there were more videos using jquery silvelight and asp.net mvc Tim I wish there were more videos using jquery silvelight and asp.net mvc

]]> By: POLL: Silverlight developer patterns http://joel.neubeck.net/2009/02/poll-separation-pattern/comment-page-1/#comment-755 POLL: Silverlight developer patterns Tue, 10 Feb 2009 21:14:59 +0000 http://joel.neubeck.net/?p=334#comment-755 [...] Poll: What separation pattern do you prefer in Silverlight development? tags: silverlight, mvvm, mvc, mvp, xaml, wpf, patterns, m-v-vm, viewmodelThis work is licensed [...] [...] Poll: What separation pattern do you prefer in Silverlight development? tags: silverlight, mvvm, mvc, mvp, xaml, wpf, patterns, m-v-vm, viewmodelThis work is licensed [...]

]]> By: John Papa http://joel.neubeck.net/2009/02/poll-separation-pattern/comment-page-1/#comment-754 John Papa Tue, 10 Feb 2009 18:58:53 +0000 http://joel.neubeck.net/?p=334#comment-754 I voted MVVM, but MVP is a close second. I think MVP is easier for people to grasp while MVVM has a lot more that people have to get their arms around. The true answer is always it depends, but generally I choose MVVM. When I consult, sometimes we choose no separation pattern to start out with. When people are learning REST, Astoria, and Silverlight already its tough to throw a pattern at them like this. Usually I ease them into one that suits their team's skills. Sometimes we get caught up in patterns and guidance while many developers are just trying to get a handle on getting the job done. But for me ... I use MVVM foremost and MVP secondarily. I voted MVVM, but MVP is a close second. I think MVP is easier for people to grasp while MVVM has a lot more that people have to get their arms around. The true answer is always it depends, but generally I choose MVVM.

When I consult, sometimes we choose no separation pattern to start out with. When people are learning REST, Astoria, and Silverlight already its tough to throw a pattern at them like this. Usually I ease them into one that suits their team’s skills. Sometimes we get caught up in patterns and guidance while many developers are just trying to get a handle on getting the job done.

But for me … I use MVVM foremost and MVP secondarily.

]]>